An FM services contract usually runs for three to five years, and most of the problems owners live with during that time were visible in the bids. A manpower schedule that cannot cover the rota, a KPI regime the bidder never priced, a mobilisation plan with no asset survey. This guide sets out how owners in the GCC evaluate facility management service tenders: what Dubai government rules require, how to score the technical offer, how to compare prices fairly, a worked example with three bidders, and the red flags worth a written clarification.
Key takeaways
- Fix the method before the bids arrive. Criteria, weights, the pass mark and the award rule belong in the tender documents, not in the evaluation meeting.
- Check compliance first, then score. A bid that fails a mandatory requirement should not reach the price comparison.
- Normalise prices before comparing them. Fixed fees, call-out rates, materials mark-ups and unpriced items make raw totals misleading.
- Score what you will later measure. The KPIs and staffing promised in the bid should become the monthly scorecard after award.
What Dubai Government Rules Require
Private owners, developers and master communities set their own tender rules. Government entities do not. In Dubai, procurement by government entities is governed by Law No. 12 of 2020 Concerning Contracts and Warehouse Management in the Government of Dubai. Even if you are not bound by it, it is a useful reference because it sets out a complete, tested sequence. The points that matter most for an FM services tender:
| Topic | What the law says | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Method | Public tender is the primary procurement method. | 23 |
| Tender documents | Must fully and clearly set the technical specifications and the scope of the requested services, and require uniform pricing. | 24 |
| Cost estimate | A market price survey sets the estimated cost, used as the reference when comparing bid prices. | 25 |
| Unpriced items | An unpriced item is treated as excluded. For an indivisible contract the bid may still be accepted, using the highest price in other bids for comparison and the lowest for award. | 28 |
| Bid bond | Set by the entity, but no more than 2% of the estimated tender value. | 31 |
| Assessment | The committee carries out both a financial and a technical assessment, and may use internal or external experts. | 33 |
| Sole bid | May be accepted or rejected; if rejected the tender is re-run, and a second sole bid must be negotiated. | 34 |
| Award rule | Lowest priced bid that meets the conditions and specifications. The next lowest may be chosen if it is more compliant, with a reasoned decision backed by the assessments. | 36 |
| Disqualification | Including late bids, collusion, unclear bids and bids that fail the tender requirements. | 37 |
| Records | All actions recorded in minutes signed by the chairman and members. | 39 |
| Performance bond | 10% of the bid value, valid 90 days after the end of a services contract, unless the Department of Finance prescribes otherwise. | 40 |
Two things follow for FM. First, the law is a lowest-compliant-price regime with a reasoned exception, so quality has to be secured through the specification and the compliance check, not only through a score. Second, Article 25 means the entity should know what the service ought to cost before it opens a single envelope. Federal entities and the other emirates have their own procurement legislation, so check which law applies to the buyer before you copy any of these rules into a tender.
The Evaluation Process Step by Step
- Pre-tender estimate. Build your own cost from the asset list, the manpower you expect and current rates. It is the yardstick for every price you receive.
- Compliance check. Pass or fail against mandatory items: licences, bonds, insurances, signed forms, every schedule completed. Record the reason for every exclusion.
- Technical scoring. Each evaluator scores alone against the published criteria, then the panel agrees a moderated score and writes down why.
- Price normalisation. Put every bid on the same basis before comparing totals (see below).
- Clarifications. Written questions to bidders, with written answers that become part of the bid. Clarifications explain a bid; they must not let a bidder change it.
- Combined ranking. Apply the published award rule: lowest compliant price, or weighted technical and commercial score.
- Award. A recommendation with the scores, the reasons and the minutes, approved by whoever holds the authority.
Scoring the Technical Offer
The technical criteria should test whether the bidder can deliver your scope on your sites, not how polished the proposal looks. The table below is an example set for an integrated hard and soft services contract. The weights are illustrative: set your own and publish them.
| Criterion | What to look for | Example weight |
|---|---|---|
| Mobilisation and transition | A dated plan for the first 90 days: asset survey, handover from the incumbent, staff onboarding, CAFM set-up and the first PPM cycle. | 15% |
| Staffing and manpower schedule | Headcount by trade and shift that matches the rota and coverage you need, supervision ratios, and how leave and absence are covered. | 20% |
| Maintenance approach | PPM schedules by asset class, statutory inspections, how reactive work is prioritised and how the backlog is controlled. | 20% |
| KPIs, SLAs and reporting | Acceptance of your KPI regime and deductions, response and resolution times by priority, and the monthly report they will produce. | 15% |
| Health, safety and environment | Permit to work, method statements, incident reporting and the record of the proposed site team. | 10% |
| Systems and proof of work | How jobs are logged, assigned and closed, and what evidence (time stamps, photos, sign-off) the owner will see. | 10% |
| Relevant experience | Comparable buildings, scope and contract size, with references you can call. | 10% |
Use a scoring scale with written definitions
A 0 to 5 scale works well if each point is defined, for example: 0 not addressed, 1 major gaps, 2 partly meets, 3 meets the requirement, 4 meets with useful detail specific to our sites, 5 exceeds with evidence. Without definitions, two evaluators can give the same answer a 2 and a 4. Set a technical pass mark (for example 60 out of 100) and state in the documents that bids below it will not be evaluated commercially.
Comparing Prices Fairly
FM bids rarely arrive on the same basis. Before comparing totals, normalise them:
- Split the price the same way for everyone. Fixed monthly fee per service line, manpower rates, call-out and after-hours rates, materials and spares mark-up, consumables and subcontracted specialist services.
- Price a standard basket. Apply each bidder's rates to the same assumed volume of reactive jobs and materials, so a low fixed fee with high call-out rates is visible.
- Deal with unpriced items consistently. Dubai's rule (Article 28) is a good default: compare using the highest price other bidders gave for that item.
- Check the manpower arithmetic. The priced headcount should match the staffing in the technical offer.
- Compare against your estimate. A bid far below it is a risk to clarify, not a saving to bank.
A common formula for the commercial score is: lowest compliant price divided by the bid price, multiplied by the commercial weight. The lowest compliant bid gets the full commercial points and the others score in proportion.
Worked Example: Three Bidders
A private owner tenders hard and soft services for a mixed-use building. The documents publish a 70% technical and 30% commercial weighting, a technical pass mark of 60 out of 100, and the formula above. Prices are normalised annual totals.
| Bidder | Technical score | Annual price (AED) | Technical points (x 0.7) | Commercial points | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | 78 | 4,200,000 | 54.6 | 3.60 / 4.20 x 30 = 25.7 | 80.3 |
| Bidder B | 64 | 3,600,000 | 44.8 | 30.0 | 74.8 |
| Bidder C | 58 | 3,100,000 | Below pass mark | Not evaluated | Excluded |
Bidder C has the lowest price but fails the technical pass mark, so its price never enters the comparison and does not set the benchmark. Bidder A wins on the combined score despite costing AED 600,000 a year more than Bidder B. The panel should be able to say what that buys: in this case a fuller manpower schedule and acceptance of the owner's KPI deductions, which Bidder B had qualified.
Run the same bids through a lowest-compliant-price rule like Dubai's Article 36 and Bidder B wins, unless the committee records a reasoned decision that Bidder A is more compliant with the specification. That is why government buyers have to write quality into the specification itself: staffing levels, KPI acceptance and reporting as mandatory requirements, not only as scored ones.
Red Flags to Clarify
- Qualifications or exclusions buried in a covering letter, especially against KPI deductions, liability caps or the asset list.
- A manpower schedule that does not cover the shifts, leave and public holidays your sites need.
- PPM frequencies lower than the specification, or statutory inspections priced as extras.
- No asset survey in mobilisation, which usually leads to a variation claim once the real condition is found.
- Materials priced at cost plus an undefined mark-up, or a very low fixed fee with high call-out rates.
- Generic method statements with another client's name or a different building type left in.
- No clear answer on how the owner will see job records, evidence and the monthly KPI calculation.
From the Winning Bid to the Contract Scorecard
The evaluation should not end at award. The staffing, response times and KPIs the winner promised are the baseline for the contractor performance scorecard you will run every month, and the SLA terms you scored become the deductions you apply. Write them into the contract in the same words, and agree before mobilisation which system holds the job records both sides will use to calculate them.
Where Reflexion fits
Preparing an FM services tender?
We can show how the KPIs and SLAs you put in the tender are tracked and scored once the contract starts, so the evaluation and the monthly scorecard use the same measures.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are facility management tenders evaluated?
Most owners run two stages. The technical offer is checked against mandatory requirements and scored against weighted criteria such as mobilisation, staffing, the maintenance approach, the KPI regime and health and safety. Bids that pass the technical stage then have their prices normalised and compared. The award goes to the lowest compliant price or to the best combined technical and commercial score, depending on the rules the tender documents set out.
What technical and commercial weighting should an FM tender use?
No law sets one split for private owners, so it is a choice that should be written into the tender documents before bids arrive. Owners who want to buy on quality put more weight on the technical score and set a technical pass mark; owners with a tightly defined scope put more weight on price. Whatever the split, publish it with the tender and do not change it after the bids are opened.
Do Dubai government entities have to award FM contracts to the lowest bid?
Under Law No. 12 of 2020, Article 36, the committee selects the lowest priced bid that meets the conditions and specifications. It may accept the next lowest bid if it is more compliant with the specifications, provided the decision is reasoned and supported by the technical and financial assessments.
What bonds are required in a Dubai government FM tender?
Law No. 12 of 2020 caps the bid bond at 2% of the estimated tender value (Article 31) and sets the performance bond at 10% of the bid value, valid for 90 days after the end of a services contract, unless the Department of Finance prescribes otherwise (Article 40).
How do you spot an unrealistically low FM bid?
Compare the priced manpower schedule with the staffing the bidder proposes in the technical offer, check that every service line and asset group is priced, and compare the total with your own pre-tender cost estimate. A bid that is far below the estimate, or that prices fewer staff than its own method statement needs, should be clarified in writing before it is scored.
Related reading
FM Contractor Performance Evaluation
Turning the KPIs you tendered into a monthly scorecard with deductions.
CAFM RFP Template
Requirements and a scoring sheet for buying the software, not the service.
Technician Proof of Work
The evidence owners should expect to see for every closed job.
Facility Management Companies in the UAE
A directory of providers to invite to tender.
