Reflexion CAFM logo
Operations Guide

Cleaning Audit Checklist: How to Score a Contractor

By Lattice Software Solutions8 min read

Most soft services contracts in the Gulf say the contractor will keep the building “clean to a high standard”. That sentence cannot be measured, so it cannot be enforced. A cleaning audit turns it into a number: a list of elements per area, a pass or fail rule for each, a target score and an audit frequency. This guide gives owners and FM managers a checklist they can use to audit a cleaning contractor, a scoring method taken from the most detailed public standard available, and a worked example from a Dubai mall food court.

Key takeaways

  • Rank areas by risk first. The target score and how often you audit both follow from the risk category.
  • Score elements, not impressions. Each element passes or fails; the score is the share that passed.
  • The highest-risk rooms cap the rating. A food court cannot score top marks while its washrooms miss their target.
  • Audit the process too. Check chemicals, dilution and colour coding, not only how the floor looks.

Which Standard to Audit Against

There is no UAE or Saudi standard that sets cleaning audit scores for commercial buildings. Dubai Municipality's guidance covers products and disinfection technique, not how clean a lobby must look. The most complete public framework for measuring cleanliness is the National Standards of Healthcare Cleanliness 2025 from NHS England, which replaced the 2021 version. It is written for hospitals, but its method (risk categories, element lists, target scores, audit frequencies, star ratings and rectification times) can be applied to any building.

Cleaning is the largest part of soft FM in most malls and offices, which is why it deserves the same measured approach owners already apply to planned maintenance. The steps below adapt the NHS method. Where a figure comes from the NHS standard, we say so; the mapping of commercial areas is our own suggestion.

Step 1: Rank Areas by Risk

The NHS standard puts every area into one of six functional risk categories, FR1 to FR6. The category sets the target score and how often the area is audited. You do not need all six; the standard itself allows an organisation to use fewer, as long as the reasoning is written down.

Risk categoryNHS target scoreNHS audit frequencyCommercial building example (our mapping)
FR198% and aboveWeeklyRarely needed outside healthcare and food production
FR295% and aboveMonthlyPublic washrooms, food court seating, prayer room ablutions
FR390% and aboveEvery 2 monthsMain entrances, lift lobbies, malls' common corridors
FR485% and aboveEvery 3 monthsOffice floors, meeting rooms, staff rest areas
FR580% and aboveEvery 6 monthsBack-of-house corridors, loading bays, stores
FR675% and aboveEvery 12 monthsPlant room floors, car park ramps, roof areas
Targets and frequencies from Table 1 of the NHS England standards (2025). The right-hand column is a suggested mapping, not part of the standard.

Areas often mix risks. A food court has washrooms, seating and a service corridor. The NHS method handles this with a “blended” area: each room keeps its own category, and the area target is the average of the room targets weighted by the number of rooms. A higher-risk room is still audited at its own frequency. The worked example below uses both rules.

Step 2: The Checklist by Area

Each area gets a fixed list of elements. An element passes when it is free of visible dust, dirt, marks and debris, stocked where relevant, and in the condition the specification asks for. Keep the lists short enough to finish each area in one walk.

Washrooms and ablutions

  • Floor, including corners, behind pans and around floor drains
  • Toilets, urinals and bidet sprays, inside and outside
  • Wash basins, taps and counters
  • Mirrors and glass
  • Soap, paper and sanitiser dispensers: clean and stocked
  • Bins: emptied, lined, clean outside
  • Walls, partitions and doors, including handles and locks
  • Odour: none noticeable on entry

Food court and dining areas

  • Tables and chairs, including undersides and legs
  • Floor, with attention to spills and sticky patches
  • Tray return points and waste stations
  • Hand-wash points and sanitiser stands
  • High-touch points: door push plates, handrails, lift buttons
  • Low surfaces: skirting, planters, seating bases

Entrances, lobbies and corridors

  • Entrance matting and the first metres of floor inside the door
  • Glass doors, revolving doors and glazed screens
  • Lift cars: floor, walls, mirrors, buttons, door tracks
  • Escalator handrails and landing plates
  • Signage, reception desks and seating
  • High surfaces: ledges, vents, light fittings within reach

Offices and back-of-house

  • Desks and work surfaces that are clear of personal items
  • Floors and carpets
  • Pantries: sink, counter, fridge exterior, microwave
  • Bins and waste holding areas
  • Service corridors and loading bays: floor, walls, waste spills
  • Cleaner's store: tidy, chemicals labelled, equipment clean

Use judgement, and write it down

The NHS standard tells auditors that one or two scuff marks on a floor, an isolated smudge on a window or a tissue dropped in an otherwise clean area should not be scored as a fail. Agree a short list of these calls with the contractor before the first audit, so disputes are about the building, not the rules.

Step 3: Score and Rate

The score for a room is the number of elements that passed divided by the number checked. The area score adds up passes and checks across all rooms audited. The NHS standard then converts the score into a star rating against the target for that risk category. For an FR2 area with a 95% target, the bands are:

Actual score (FR2, 95% target)Star rating
95% and above5 stars
92% to 94%4 stars
89% to 91%3 stars
86% to 88%2 stars
85% or below1 star
Appendix 6, NHS England standards (2025). Each category has its own bands, about three points wide below its target.

Two rules from the standard are worth copying into any contract. First, in a blended area the rating is capped by the highest-risk rooms: if they miss their own target, the area cannot get five stars, however good the rest is. Second, the rating comes from the original audit score and is not raised after the contractor fixes the faults; it changes only at the next full audit. Areas at three stars or fewer need an improvement plan with dates.

Record the score by responsible party as well. In a mall, the cleaning contractor, the maintenance team and the tenants may each be responsible for different elements in the same area. The NHS standard keeps one rating for the area but splits the percentage by staff group, so you can see who caused the gap.

Step 4: Rectification Times

Every failed element becomes a task with a deadline. The NHS standard ties both the time to assess a reported problem and the time to fix it to the risk category; the fix is due at the next scheduled clean or within the limit below, whichever comes first.

Risk categoryAssess withinFix within
FR120 minutes2 hours
FR220 minutes4 hours
FR31 hour12 hours
FR41 hour72 hours
FR524 hours96 hours
FR624 hours120 hours
Rectification times from the NHS England standards (2025), or the next scheduled clean if sooner.

Logging each fail as a timed job, rather than a line in a PDF report, is what lets you check later that it was closed on time.

Step 5: Audit the Cleaning Process

A visual audit shows the result at one moment. The NHS standard adds an efficacy audit, which checks the process at the point of work: correct colour coding, equipment, materials and method. In a Gulf building, add the local product rules. Dubai Municipality's cleaning and disinfection guideline (DM-HSD-GU87-CDBE2) tells users to prepare disinfectants as the manufacturer instructs, leave the right contact time, and use biocides from the Municipality's published list of approved professional-use products.

  • Are the disinfectants in use on the Dubai Municipality approved biocides list?
  • Are solutions mixed to the label dilution and freshly prepared?
  • Is the product left on the surface for its stated contact time?
  • Are cloths and mops colour coded, with washroom kit kept apart from food areas?
  • Is equipment clean and in working order, and are chemicals labelled and stored safely?
  • Does the cleaner follow the method in the cleaning specification for that area?

Worked Example: A Dubai Mall Food Court

A shopping mall treats its food court as one blended area with 12 audit zones: 4 washrooms (FR2, 95%), 6 seating zones (FR3, 90%) and 2 service corridor sections (FR4, 85%). The blended target is (4 × 95 + 6 × 90 + 2 × 85) ÷ 12 = 90.8%, rounded to 91%. The FR2 washrooms set the audit frequency: monthly. The figures below are illustrative.

ZonesTargetElements checkedPassedScoreRating
4 washrooms (FR2)95%403792.5%4 stars
6 seating zones (FR3)90%484695.8%5 stars
2 corridor sections (FR4)85%141392.9%5 stars
Food court (blended)91%1029694.1%4 stars (capped)
Illustrative audit. The area beats its 91% target, but the rating is capped at the washrooms' 4 stars.

The food court scores 94.1%, above its target, yet it is rated four stars because the washrooms reached 92.5% against their 95% target. The three washroom fails (an empty soap dispenser, a stained floor drain and a smeared mirror) become three jobs due within 4 hours or at the next clean. The washroom fails also go to the next monthly contractor review, where repeated misses on the same element count against the soft services KPI.

Linking the Audit to the Contract

An audit only changes behaviour if the contract uses it. Write the risk categories, element lists, targets, frequencies and rectification times into the soft services specification, and name the audit score as a KPI with a defined deduction, as you would for response times. Our guide to FM contractor performance evaluation shows how to weight it inside a monthly scorecard. Agree who audits (the NHS standard recommends the contractor takes part, with joint audits where possible) and keep the evidence: photos of fails, time of audit and who signed.

Paper audits make this hard. Scores sit in spreadsheets, photos sit on phones, and nobody can show six months later which zone failed and when it was fixed. An inspection app built for this, such as Reflexion FieldINSPECT, lets you build the checklist with your own scoring rules, tie each audit to a building, floor and zone, attach geo-tagged photos to each failed element, capture signatures and produce a PDF report with the scores, so the history of every zone is kept in one place.

Want to audit your cleaning contractor on a phone?

We will show a cleaning audit checklist in FieldINSPECT, scored by zone, with photos and signatures.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should a building owner audit the cleaning contractor?

Tie the frequency to the risk of each area, not to a single calendar. The NHS England cleanliness standards, the most detailed public framework, audit their highest-risk areas weekly and their lowest-risk areas once a year, with monthly, two-monthly, three-monthly and six-monthly steps in between. A commercial building can borrow the same ladder: washrooms and food courts monthly or more, offices and back-of-house quarterly or less.

What is a good cleaning audit score?

It depends on the area. The NHS framework sets targets from 98% for the highest-risk areas down to 75% for the lowest. For a mall or office, a sensible starting point is 95% for washrooms and food areas, 90% for public circulation and 85% for offices and back-of-house. Write the targets into the contract so both sides audit against the same number.

Should one dirty item fail the whole area?

No. Each element (floors, mirrors, bins, dispensers) is marked pass or fail, and the score is the share of elements that pass. The NHS guidance also asks auditors to use judgement: one scuff mark or an isolated smudge in an otherwise clean area should not be scored as a fail. Agree these rules with the contractor before the first audit.

Which cleaning chemicals are allowed in Dubai?

Dubai Municipality publishes a list of approved professional-use (business-to-business) biocides on its Health and Safety Department pages, and its cleaning and disinfection guideline refers users to that list. Check that the contractor's disinfectants appear on it, and that they are diluted and left for the contact time the manufacturer specifies.

Related reading

Browse the FM glossary

Book a 30-minute walkthrough

Pick a time that suits you. Tell us about your buildings or your FM contracts, and we'll walk you through Reflexion with examples close to your own operation.